Showing posts with label moral law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label moral law. Show all posts

Friday, November 03, 2006

(Perhaps) The Most Heroic Job...... Ever

A long time ago (almost a year now) I blogged about the moviefilm "The Constant Gardener". Not an attractive movie title, I admit, but an absolutely amazing film which highlights some extremely pertinent social issues while preserving the highest aesthetic quality possible.

I wrote, at the time,
"Pharmaceutical companies test drugs for side effects on Africans who are going to die anyway, either of HIV, or of the many other dieseases that are easily treatable if only there were the resources. Hopefully, no one will tell me that these companies are doing a good thing by making sure those drugs will work for us. But would you use such a drug if you'd die without it? What if you didn't know about the exploits? How can we stop the illicit acts of these profit-driven corporations? They are motivated merely by the "golden" economic laws of supply and demand..."
David Friedman (Milton's son) suggests in "Drugs for Africa: A Modest Proposal" to
1) Let charitable donors in rich countries buy out the patent on the second best AIDS drug or combination of drugs and public domain it—let anyone who wants make it.

2) Make FDA [design] rules on testing so as to encourage drug companies to make not yet approved drugs available abroad in order to use the information so generated to meet the requirements for approval in the U.S.
The first suggestion is a sound idea, both pragmatic and socially beneficial. However, the second proposal really bothers me, despite the lack of a feasible alternative. According to Friedman, people like me will
[Make] good demagogic use of the idea that it is wicked to use human beings as guinea pigs for potentially dangerous drugs—despite the fact that using humans as guinea pigs is the only way we have of finding out whether or not drugs are safe.
The fallacy is why should people with less money be the only ones targeted as guinea pigs? If we believe in universal human rights, then the status of a human being in Zambia should be no less than one in Arkansas, Faroe Islands or Timbuktu. Why are some lives put at risk so that others can benefit?

Should the guinea pig option not be a voluntary activity, open for participation to people from all places by providing compensation (aka cash incentive) for the risk? Risk is inevitable in a fireman's job, yet there are plenty of people who willingly take up the job. Same goes for policemen. Drug testing is as heroic a job as theirs. Volunteers accept a certain amount of risk by helping to save people in the future. Surely that job should merit an amount of respect such that the applicant pool for firemen and policemen would consider it.

That said, I know that Africans will end up as the guinea pigs because the cash incentive (*cough* wage) would be the lowest. I wonder: if one day we are able to outsource dangerous jobs like firefighting to poorer countries (e.g. via teleporting), will we have any more firefighters in rich countries?

We are, in the end, just outsourcing "guinea pig" jobs to Africa.

Tuesday, August 29, 2006

When I Look At The World...

You have dreams. You have ideals. You want to help. You want to make a difference.

That's all you ever wanted. Heal the world. Or just do something. Feed the malnourished. Vaccinate the sick. Educate the illiterate. Lend a hand to the handicapped, the elderly, the socially disadvantaged, the unfortunate. Give a leg up to immigrants, refugees, minimum wage families, the unemployed. Sounds so good and altruistic, doesn't it?

Well, it never is as easy as it sounds. Nothing ever is. I certainly haven't heard of anything that is. Perhaps I'm just skeptical. I used to be idealistic, in the not too distant yet already far away past. I still am, but reality runs you over, mashes you up the way a bullet train grazes through hamburgers.

Selling girl scout cookies? Raising money for a breast cancer fund? Keeping old people company? Doing immigrant children's homework over the phone? Maybe it helps. Maybe it doesn't. And I'm probably leaning towards the negative. Why?

3 reasons: high OC, dramatic BP, and often unattractive LES.

Opportunity Cost - volunteers waste an exorbitant amount of their talent and time in the process of charity work. Smart volunteers could usually effect more change through the inherent job nature or simply by donating their high wages The humanitarian efforts are worth something if and only if the program or project is run in an extremely smooth manner - which rarely happens.

Bureaucracy & Politics - charity organizations, like any other sizable group, have plenty of administrative problems to worry about, yet they lack the quintessential incentive to maximize productivity since they are often non-profit parties. They usually attempt to have many layers of decision-making in order to divide up the labor, yet more often than not result in completely pointless job titles and altogether ineffective governing.

Leadership Efficiency Scale - only idealistic yet intelligent people can mold volunteering into a worthy (aka profitable) venture. And those people choose (based on  the 1st reason) to contribute through other channels, perhaps due to the high level of investment (and low return) required at the beginning stage. Moreover, resources (both human and monetary) are almost never devoted in the most efficacious way possible, where help is needed the most or where the most help can be done. Even charity follows 'Economies of Scale'.


My lesson from Pinghu : Summer 2006.

Compassion alone is not enough.

Friday, June 09, 2006

A Changing World: Good or Bad?

Ever felt that when browsing through Wikipedia looking up one thing, you end up learning about something completely different? Or am I the only person random enough to surf aimlessly for information?

Thanks to Web 2.0, I get this uneasy feeling that advances in Internet technology is only contributing to increased amounts of internet procrastination, affecting especially those budding minds of young college students. Under the broad umbrella term of interactive websites, those that above all focus their free time on forming links and relationships among youngsters or students, have become increasingly a magnet for procrastinating teenagers (e.g. Me) and a source of unproductivity.

(See this list for some of the culprits.)

It is undeniable that not all of these sites do only harm. LJ, Xanga and other blogging sites provide a completely novel way for young people to vent, to express, or to opine, not that many of them do more than rant randomly about how life sucks (again, e.g. Me). However, it isn't the first time that I'm complaining about how some people profile themselves so freely on the no-longer-neutral Internet.

"...telecommunications and cable companies will be able to create toll lanes on the information superhighway... This strikes at the heart of the free and equal nature of the internet."

Not only that, but has anyone any idea what others do with their profiles? Perhaps this would scare you off. Or maybe you'd be indifferent. I opt to proceed with caution. No unrestrained advertising of personal information when the NSA is snooping around for my every move.

By adding online social networking data to its phone analyses, the NSA could connect people at deeper levels, through shared activities, such as taking flying lessons. - New Scientist

Maybe an American is willing to give up some privacy in the name of National Security, but to me, they're just masking a non-stop slippery slope all the way back to 1984. Perhaps it's my panicky self after watching 24, but I'm not surprised if the PRC equivalent isn't worming its way into HK networks. Not even if they've already established the foundations for a Great Firewall - HK.

Friday, June 02, 2006

Are you reading this?

I read many things that interest me that would otherwise seem like a waste of time to many others. This is one of them.

News nowadays is transferred through both traditional and modern media. People still read newspapers & magazines, listen to the radio, and watch news reports. But other people, usually those half the age of the first category, receive their news from elsewhere. 'Internet' is only an umbrella term. There are websites from Reuters, CNN, BBC, or NYT. There's Google News, a portal (*cough* computer program) consolidating content from across the web. There's Wikinews, self-published and community-monitored news from anywhere, anytime if you think it's important. There are Blogs if you feel self-righteous or protective about what you write.

New forms of news have popped up across the world (at least the wired part, that is). I didn't come across News.com until today! And it's great in that it not only writes great editorials but also has a 'Big Picture' function informing you of how all the news is related, like this particular piece.

You know how Google News ranks news according to relevance? Well, there's this new site digg.com that doesn't rely (*cough* trust) a computer algorithm tuned by Google's computer engineers. It allows users to submit relevant stories and also to vote on which ones they think should be the headlines, rather than let some authoritative editor to do the job. Remember how Wikipedia lets YOU edit whatever content you feel is incorrect? Guess what? You can do that even to websites! Check out Wetpaint.com and what they can do.

It's fascinating and wonderful how in the world now we are no longer limited to news that people feed into our mouths (though some still opt for that option), but can pick from an assortment of Social, Wiki, and Personal media. But don't forget, when you're browsing happily, that there are people who do not have the same rights that you do, however close they may be.

Friends, in China, you can't even use Gmail. In China, you can't access Wikipedia. In China, any politically sensitive blogs even remotely related is filtered, censored, or blocked. Reflect on that. Cherish the freedom that you possess.